City of Troy Home
Monument Square

Troy Teasures: Fifth Avenue
Troy Record, March 9, 2003

 


Fifth Avenue between Jacob and Hutton Streets is an interesting one-block stretch of residential and business properties, parking lots, and some green spaces and churches.

St. Peter's Church (once one of the richest parishes in Troy) is to the north and Bethel Baptist Church to the south; a church between the two was torn down several years ago due to structural damages. Built in the mid- to late 1800s, this block of architecturally beautiful houses was once home to a vibrant immigrant population of Italians, Irish, Jews and Armenians, among others, that lived, ran businesses, worshipped, and shopped there.

"Columbus Square," at the corner of Fifth and Jacob, was designated in 1892 to commemorate the 400th anniversary of Christopher Columbus' discovery of America. There was a large water fountain there that doubled as a water trough for horses until it was demolished when a fire truck crashed into it, leaving nothing but a bare traffic "island."

In 1992, on the 500th anniversary of Columbus' discovery, the Sons of Italy commissioned a statute to be built on that site honoring immigrants. The "Columbus Monument," designed by Joe Fama, depicts a map of the world with Columbus' route and a bow of a ship pointing west. Plaques adorn the site with the names of immigrants to Troy from all over the world.

This portion of Fifth Avenue and the surrounding blocks was a bustling vital commercial and residential area for years. Longtime residents of Troy - some of whom still live on Fifth Avenue - remember the Armenian meat market; Ben Katz' furniture store; DeChristopher's, where one could get ice cream and other food; Italian markets; lawyers' offices; two glass stores; bars and more.

B-Lann, an industrial safety and fire protection equipment supply company at the corner of Fifth and Hutton streets, has been in existence since 1946 when it was started by the parents of the current owners, Nick and Tom Flannery. Their father was born in the house across the street in 1910, in a building that was previously a hotel where Irish immigrants could stay for free until they "got on their feet" and moved on, making room for other immigrants.

The street was immortalized in a famous Norman Rockwell painting of a family passing a bar on their way to church, which is believed by some to have been inspired by this stretch of Fifth Avenue.

One of the bars on the block was not so fondly remembered, with a "house of ill repute" operating upstairs. In fact, when the Troy Rehabilitation and Improvement Program (TRIP) rehabilitated this building in 1986, 22 bullets were pulled out of the walls. One of these bullets was left on the floor during the newly rehabbed building's ribbon-cutting with the NYS Division of Housing and Community Renewal, which provided state subsidies to the project, prompting the Deputy Commissioner to scoop it up and take it home as a souvenir.

Today, the block looks very different from previous decades. Many buildings have been torn down to create parking lots for area businesses. Other lots host a community garden, "Father Flanagan's Farm," named after the longtime priest at St. Peter's Church who created the garden 18 years ago and who died last year. Other properties stand abandoned. A barricade stands at one end of the street, erected by the police to reduce potential drug traffic off the Green Island Bridge.

Residents of the block care deeply about the neighborhood. A neighborhood watch group, the Fifth Avenue Neighborhood (FAN) Club, is currently forming to "assist in implementing a better, more beautiful, safer neighborhood to live in and enjoy."

Ideas include beautifying the street through flower-plantings, increasing the sense of community by get-togethers, and dealing with some of the problems that occasionally plague the neighborhood. If you are interested in joining, please contact C.J. Marbley at 266-9955.

Co-Authored by C.J. Marbley, coordinator of Fifth Avenue Neighborhood (FAN) Club and Hilary Lamishaw, director of Community Affairs at TRIP.

 

Home